In our December look at agency Internet marketing, the first question in our reader survey was, “Does your agency/brokerage have a Web site?” The response was 81%. Why not 100%, you might ask.

Another person asking was Duke Williams, a blogger and consultant on agency Internet use. Last month, Duke decided to conduct an informal survey of “feet on the street results for actual agency Web presence.” His methodology was simple: he used the “find an agent” feature on many insurance carrier Web sites, and Googled the term “car insurance city name state name.” He used the SuperPages, YellowPages and about a half dozen other lists online.

In individually searching several locations in South Carolina, North Carolina, Georgia, Alabama and Florida, he found:

• 248 independent agencies
• 49 Nationwide agencies
• 19 online-only agencies
• 51 State Farm agencies
• 26 Allstate agencies
• 7 Farmers agencies
• 7 Alpha agencies
• 2 Farm Bureau agencies
• 1 GEICO local agency
• 1 Direct General agency (rregional non-standard auto insurance carrier with owned agency locations)

While these results seem to indicate a strong presence for independent agencies, a closer look tells another story. Of the 248 independent agencies that came up in the search, only 64 — a paltry 25.8% — had a Web site, and only a fraction turned up in the Google “local results” search.

Delving deeper, Duke discovered that the agencies with Web sites weren’t consistent in functionality, even in non-real-time. For instance, 51.6% had quote request forms, but only 12.5% had “request a policy change” forms, and only 20.3% had “report a claim” forms. Not surprisingly, Duke reported that all the national direct writers had very high functionality.

While you could argue that Duke’s results are atypical — focused on a limited geographic area and a single line of business — you’d be missing the point. In every way, direct writers are making it easy for consumers to find and use their products and services — and it isn’t all about price.

Woody Allen once said that “80% of success is showing up.” When it comes to Web pages, the odds are even better if you show up with a functional product that makes it as easy as possible for people to use what you have to offer.

Last month we posted an interview on our Web page with Progressive’s  Karen Barone, national distribution leader for agency business, which proved to be 0ne of our most popular features.

Not surprisingly, part of the article’s interest — or more accurately, controversy — involves Progressive’s promotion of direct purchase along with sales through its agency force. 

Many of our readers pointed to Progressive’s heavy TV advertising — currently featuring the wacky saleswoman character, “Flo” — as testimony to its commitmemt to direct sales and cutting out the middleman. Surprisingly, in spite of the prevalence of Progressive advertising promoting direct sales,  Barone noted that about 65 percent of Progressive’s sales actually come through its more than 30,000 independent agencies.

Now, in recognition of that fact, Progressive is unveiling on Oct. 19 a new Flo commercial, featuring — you got it — an independent agent. (Well, actually, he’s an actor playing an independent agent, kind of like actress Angelina Jolie will play me in “The Laura Toops Story,” but you get the idea.) And, taking a tip from other industry branding programs (remember the Big I and Raymond Burr?), Progressive agents can even access a version of the commercial they can customize with their agency’s branding to run locally.

The thinking behind this move seems pretty sound — an attempt to promote the insurer’s already prevalent independent agency sales. But the end of the commercial — a voiceover that states, “Prices vary based on how you buy” — sums up the controversy. Because, of course, consumers who buy directly through Progressive will pay less than those who go through an agent.

Do you think Progressive’s new campaign will increase agency sales?